The art of the animateur

I am a great fan of the late John Drummond, and have quoted him, here, many times. But, I blame Drummond for the present decline in presentation standards on BBC Radio 3. In 1987, when he became controller of the network, Drummond changed the role of the presentation team from 'neutral' announcers to presenters who, in his own words, could "communicate enthusiasm and knowledge".

Drummond's change was well intentioned, but terribly misguided. It has been responsible for a disastrous sequence of presenters from Paul 'music for lovers' Gambaccini in the 1990s to Petroc Trelawny and his colleagues today, whose idea of communicating enthusiasm and knowledge is to regurgitate half-digested chunks from a children's encyclopedia of music. The disease isn't just confined to the radio. BBC TV's Classical Star, which is fronted by Radio 3 presenters Charles Hazlewood and Chi-chi Nwanoku, has been described by an eminent musician as 'an obscene pantomime that plays games with the feelings of young, talented and vulnerable people'.

What John Drummond failed to see was that presenters who can communicate enthusiasm and knowledge for classical music without turning it into 'an obscene pantomine' can't be trained. They are born with the skill, and they are very few and far between. 'Presenter' is an inadequate and devalued word for describing such a rare person. Instead I suggest the French word 'animateur' - someone who really brings their subject to life.

Radio 3 should abandon its present crop of 'classical jocks'. It should return to an enthusiastic but neutral presentation style. It should learn from Radio 4, which has avoided the 'chummy' presenter trap, and by so doing has retained its integrity, and its audience. Radio 3 should allow the music to speak for itself. Which is something it has forgotten how to do. And it should search for a few great animateurs to bring classical music back to life, both on radio and television.

The BBC need look no further than their own archives to identify the DNA of a great animateur. David Munrow's Pied Piper radio programme was broadcast four times a week for five years in the 1970s. Munrow (above) delivered enthusiasm and knowlege in huge quantities without compromising scholarship or integrity. Pied Piper brought early music to life for a generation, and I, and many others, are indebted to him for that. Munrow also branched out into television with his very successful Ancestral Voices programme, and he started to develop a career as a conductor. Munrow did so much as an animateur of classical music, and he promised so much more. Alas, he took his own life in 1976, aged just thirty-three.

Television was the medium of choice of another great animateur, André Previn, whose BBC TV programmes reached millions without sinking to the depths of Classical Star. The photo below shows Previn with Carlo Maria Giulini on the set of the television programme 'Who needs a conductor?' Previn also animated classical music in the States with his 'Previn and the Pittsburgh' TV series.

Leopold Stokowski pioneered the role of the animateur in the States, and he worked his magic in the days before television dictated the media agenda. Disney's full length 1940 feature film Fantasia brought classical music to life for millions, and is still regarded today as pivotal in introducing a new audience to serious music. Fantasia was Stokowski's brainchild, and he appeared on screen in a sequence which is seen being filmed in the photo below. (Picture credit Disney Productions).

When television replaced the movies as the entertainment medium of choice Leonard Bernstein took over from Stokowski' as animateur par excellence. Bernstein's famous Young Person's Concerts attracted huge television audiences for an extraordinarily wide range of repertoire, with his broadcast on Christmas Day 1967 reaching an astonishing twenty-seven million viewers.

I have in front of me the programme for the November 2 1963 telecast of a Young Person's Concert - Moussorgsky Prelude to "Khovantchina", Randall Thompson Scherzo from Symphony No. 2, Walter Piston Suite from "The Incredible Flautist", and Brahms Academic Festival Overture. Contrast that with this perceptive comment from fellow blogger Jessica Duchen about BBC TV's Classical Star - 'The most depressing thing about the programme is the way that the music itself is sidelined and chopped up. Evidently our friends at the Beeb don't think that viewers can cope with a whole movement of Mendelssohn.' My header photo shows Bernstein with members of the audience after a Young Person's Concert, and they don't seem at all phased by a whole movement of Randall Thompson. Lenny was a true animateur if ever there was one.

Glenn Gould was also both a great musician and a great animateur, and I have already written about his love affair with the microphone. His radio programme The Art of Glenn Gould ran for forty-eight weeks in the mid 1960s in Canada, and covered everything from the Moog synthesizer to Mozart, and in 1974 he produced a ten week series on Schoenberg. In the late 1960s he turned to television, starting with a series of four Conversations with Glenn Gould in a co-production with the BBC. His television work became as arcane as his radio documentaries, with the hour long The Well-Tempered Listener creating a complex visual montage of Bach's music. Gould's main succeses were in the technically more flexible medium of television. In 1970, in a neat tribute from one great animateur to another, Gould produced the acclaimed Stokowski: A Portrait for Radio. The photo below shows him at work in the recording studio.

Sadly one match of animateurs that seemed to be made in heaven didn't work out for Gould. In April 1962 he played the Brahms' D-minor concerto with Leonard Bernstein conducting the New York Philharmonic. Conductor and soloist disagreed over Gould's spectacularly slow tempi, prompting Bernstein to deliver an apparently critical pre-performance talk. The two animateurs never performed together again, although this was due as much to Gould's self-imposed exile from the concert hall as to any long-term animosity between the two flamboyant musicians.

Last week I told the story of Radio 3 presenter Sarah Walker, who was caught out (in more ways than one I suspect) when a helpful CD player added a fifth movement to Mendelssohn's Italian Symphony. Ms. Walker's CV tells us that in 1995 she completed a PhD in English experimental music. That's the problem. She, and her fellow BBC presenters may have the right qualifications on paper. But, in practice, they fail dismally; both as neutral announcers in the manner of the great Cormac Rigby, and as animateurs in the manner of David Munrow. It's not me that's saying it. It is the audience statistics.

The composer Jonathan Harvey knows a thing or two about experimental English music. He has worked at IRCAM and written a study of the music of Stockhausen. His Mortuos plango, vivos voco for eight channel tape was created at IRCAM, and uses computers to manipulate the sound of the great bell at Winchester Cathedral. It is one of the masterpieces of electronic music, and in the notes for it the composer writes:

In entering the rather intimidating world of the machine I was determined not to produce a dehumanised work if I could help it, and so kept fairly closely to the world of the original sounds. The territory that the new computer technology opens up is unprecedently vast: one is humbly aware that it will only be conquered by the penetration of the human spirit, however beguiling the exhibits of technical wizardry; and that penetration will be neither rapid nor easy.

We're all trying to be too clever. We've forgotten the importance of the human spirit, except when we are trampling it underfoot on BBC TV's Classical Star. We've missed the point that digital technologies, new books, internet radio and blogs alone are never going to attract a new mass audience for classical music. But great animateurs can.

The good news is that the art of the animateur is not dead. The opening of this autumn's Lincoln Centre season in New York was transmitted live on network television. The TV presenter was that indominatable human spirit Itzhak Perlman (photo below, credit Allegro films), and his words about the telecast are a lesson for all of us.

"Television was how I came to the States (to appear on the Ed Sullivan show - Pliable) and I've always felt very comfortable doing it. Of course, there are battles. Television will always err on the side of making something not quite as classy as it could be. I try to put my foot down because people in the mass media often don't give audiences credit. To bring a large audience to a piece of serious music and make it accessible does not mean reducing it in any way. And I've learned that if something is good, even if it is a little difficult, people will get that it is good."

Writing in the Cambridge Review in October 1957 Peter Laslett, founder of the Open University, described the BBC Third Programme as "a sevice which is literally the envy of the world". Fifty years later the service is in danger of becoming the laughing stock of the world. It doesn't need rocket science, or expensive technology, to reverse the decline. It just needs John Drummonds ill-judged presentation changes to be reversed. And it needs the BBC to remember the words of that great animateur Itzhak Perlman - "If something is good, even if it is a little difficult, people will get that it is good."

Now read how John Drummond and Leonard Bernstein just didn't hit it off.
Any copyrighted material on these pages is included as "fair use", for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis only, and will be removed at the request of copyright owner(s). Report broken links, missing images and other errors to - overgrownpath at hotmail dot co dot uk


Jeff said…
Touching to see mention of David Munrow after many years.

God rest his soul.
Pliable said…
Jeff, thanks for that.

I'm currently working on a radio documentary about David Munrow. This will include, I hope, a major contribution from a key figure in Munrow's recording career who has not told his story before.

The programme should be broadcast on Future Radio before Christmas. I'll post further details here when available.
Garth Trinkl said…
Thank you for another very important article, pliable.

Iván Fischer -- the founding music director of the Budapest Festival Orchestra and the incoming principal guest conductor (for two years) of Washington's National Symphony Orchestra -- is another humane musician who could probably easily step onto the television airwaves and radio airwaves and bring millions along to the joys of classical music. (Mr Fischer declined the National Symphony Orchestra's offer of the permanent post being vacated by Leonard Slatkin, preferring not to spend too much time away from his young family based in Budapest, and his Budapest Festival Orchestra.)

Apparently, his first classical concert for children in Washington (based upon his children's classical programming in Budapest) brought praise from the Washington Post, which described him as “informal and extroverted and pleasingly absurdist, winning the delighted laughter of the numerous children, parents, and grandparents”.

This past Sunday, he gave two more Children's classical concerts in Washington, the positive review for which is at (mid-page):


I'd love for the American Public Broadcasting Service (PBS) to invite Mr. Fischer -- or an alternative, younger, humane musician -- to launch a weekend classical music program for children and young adults on PBS's Public Television and Public Radio (if public television and radio, in America, survives the lack of attention and mismanagement of its current laissez-faire Republican and ADD limosine-liberal Democratic Boards of Governors.)
Pliable said…
Garth thanks for that, and it is indeed good news that Iván Fischer is an animateur in the making.

My experience is that talking about music is something musicians either excel at, or are really bad at.

Mark Elder has done great things with the Hallé Orchestra here. But he will insist on delivering pre-performance lectures, which come over precisely as pre-performance lectures.

I did write about musicians who talked some time back -

Now you've got me thinking about a post on the Robert Mayer Children's Concerts -
Unknown said…
I used the word important before reading Garth's comment.
Pliable said…
Totally priceless.

Bang on cue tonight BBC Radio 3 presents a recording of a Boulez/BBCSO concert from 1975.

The concert recording is presented by Tom Service who has as a guest, live in the presentation suite, Sir Robert Ponsonby, who was BBC controller of music in 1975.

In the unscripted introduction Ponsonby lays in to the current standards of BBC Radio 3 presentation, echoes every point made in my post and leaves Service lost for words.

The, after the last work, Tom Service delivers his signature mistake of leaving the guest microphone closed. ( And then does it AGAIN in the link to the next programme.

Unmissable. Boulez's Webern, Birtwistle and Ravel are pretty good as well -
Elaine Fine said…
Thank you for the word "animateur" and for this piece.
Garth Trinkl said…
Elaine, thank you for the fascinating excerpt from "Musical Notes from Abroad [1940]", from Musical Times, on your Musical Assumptions web-site! Like you, my eyes were caught by the mentions of Bartok's American recital tour with his wife [the two piano and percussion sonata]; and Paul Wittgenstein's commission of 'Diversions' from Britten (apparently written, in part, in Maine, and premiered in Philadelphia). [Clicking around, I see that Wittgenstein disliked (to no effect) Britten's orchestration; and also Ravel's use of jazz, in that commission. ]

What also caught my eye was Prokofiev's "Simeon Kotke" in Moscow. American opera might have been different if that work had travelled the Atlantic for an American production -- either on Broadway or at an opera house -- at about that time!
Pliable said…
Email received from my anonymous mentor:

Good piece, except that I think it is the dapper Giulini, not the scruffy Fleischman with Previn, and (will you ever forgive me?) practice is the spelling for the noun (under Sarah Walker, whose sloppy diction has just been infuriating me)[Both now corrected - Pliable].

The proper word for the job is announcer. I am not in the least interested in their views of the music or the performance, which are usually insolent and ill-informed.

You are so right.
Anonymous said…
A lovely item ... thank you!

I've dug around for my copy of Gould's Stokowski documentary for listening a bit later tonight. Also worthwhile is Gould's sizable essay, "Stokowski in Six Scenes," reprinted in "The Glenn Gould Reader". It talks about the making of the documentary, and also touches on his recording with Stokowski of the "Emperor".

And it has a great opening line - "I am not by nature a stage-door John".

David Munrow!! Those big LP boxes are around here somewhere ...
mrG said…
there is an essential difference between the culture producing those great moments of media you cite and the culture now producing the trite pantomimes: the former culture did not worship money, they valued education and community assets and as such they regularly programmed material that was not popular but enriching, borrowing from the Pops to cover the costs of the Greater Good. Today they cannot for fear of offending their god by not carrying their own financial weight on each individual programme event. It is no longer valid to call it BBC3 or BBC4 because it's Every Show For Themselves, not a cohesive, unified intention.

So what we have today is totally logical, and should come as no surprise since their modus operandi has been expected of their culture for as far back as anyone can remember:

"The Superior Man knows what is right; the Inferior Man knows what will sell." (Confucius)

Recent popular posts

A tale of two new audiences

Whatever happened to the long tail of composers?

The Berlin Philharmonic's darkest hour

Why new audiences are deaf to classical music

Audiences need permission to like unfamiliar music

You are looking at the future of classical music journalism

A Philippa Schuyler moment

If you only buy thirty-four CDs this year - buy these .....

Nada Brahma - Sound is God

I read the fake news today, oh boy