Thursday, January 10, 2013
Messiaen takes a trip
Examples of erroneous classical music metadata abound. In a recent post I noted how Amazon categorises Edith Canat de Chizy’s lyric drama Tombeau de Gilles de Rais as ‘Classic Rock’. And now I notice that Keith Jarrett’s improvisations for solo organ Hymns - Spheres is listed by them under ‘Concertos for orchestra’. In a 2011 post about ECM’s CD release of Spheres I wrote “it is a mystery why the label have never transferred the complete original [LP] release to CD as, for me, it is one of the best things Keith Jarrett has ever done”. Now ECM have done the right thing and re-released the complete Hymns - Spheres on 2 CDs, restoring the English Hymnal meets Gurdjieff Hymns that bookend Jarrett’s ‘Messiaen takes a trip’ improvisations in Spheres. Recorded in 1976 on the larger of the two Joseph Riell baroque organs at the Benedictine Ottobueren Abbey in Bavaria, Hymns - Spheres saw Jarrett breaking all the rules and creating new sounds by pulling organ stops part way out. Sonically the recording is still a stunner; but back in 1976 it received mixed reviews, with Jarrett lamenting “The ones in America were maybe some of the most stupid… bad reviews they were, most of them, like, ‘It doesn’t swing’”. Hymns - Spheres may not swing, but it’s a helluva trip. Talking of which, Elgar goes outrageous here.
Also on Facebook and Twitter. Hymns - Spheres was a requested review sample. Quote is from Keith Jarrett: the Man and His Music by Ian Carr. Any copyrighted material on these pages is included as "fair use", for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis only, and will be removed at the request of copyright owner(s). Report broken links, missing images and errors to - overgrownpath at hotmail dot co dot uk