So what’s killing criticism?

What’s killing criticism? The stars…

In a former life, as assistant editor of a formerly respected newspaper, I fought hard and successfully against the blight of applying star ratings to reviews of live performances. My argument was that once readers counted the stars they would not bother to read those reviews. Of all my gloomiest predictions, I fear this one has been most fully validated. When I stepped down, the stars took over.

Today, critics whose columns are unadorned by stars stand a chance of getting read down to the very end. The rest must hope for a scandal or a miracle to secure close attention from a general readership.
That condemnation of star ratings by Norman Lebrecht appears on Slipped Disc today. Above it is his latest review for Sinfini Music. As you can see, he gives the album a four star rating.

Also on Facebook and Twitter. Any copyrighted material on these pages is included as "fair use", for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis only, and will be removed at the request of copyright owner(s).

Comments

Pliable said…
Comment received from Philip Amos:

Oh, Bob, I am enjoying your pouncing upon Lebrecht's self-contradictions. I not long ago decided, having earlier found a multitude of reasons for putting it off, to read his 'Why Mahler? How One Man and Ten Symphonies Changed the World' -- gulp. I am convinced that slogging through the ghastly prose of that exercise in overblown romantic myth-making set my recuperation back at least a week.

Recent popular posts

Four great albums that are victims of clickbait correctness

Scott Ross and the paradox of genius

If this had been a Deutsche Grammophon session.....

Berlin Philharmonic's first woman conductor

Conductors who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones

Missing so much and so much.........

What the law of diminishing diversity tells us

How to reach a big new post-COVID classical audience

How classical music ignored the awakening electronic dream

Hoax that fooled music critics for 30 years