BBC TV's Classical Star condemned as 'sick'


'A society that revels in others' public distress or humiliation, filmed in intrusive close-up, is a pretty sick society. Classical Star harks back to the worst excesses of the Roman arena. The children are exhibits in a human circus. The judges use the thumbs up/thumbs down technique of the Roman emperor; they offer us pretension, patronage and a deep sense of self-importance. We are all being coarsened by this continual diet of exploitation. '

That's just one paragraph from Hilary Davan Wetton's attack on BBC TV's Classical Star in today's Guardian. He hits the nail right on the head, he says it is bad for classical music. And Hilary isn't just a grumpy old blogger. He is a musician, teacher and conductor. And his new CD of Vaughan William's seasonal Hodie is out on Naxos this week.

Now, on the day of Ursula Vaughan William's memorial service let's remember a pilgrim's final progress.
Any copyrighted material on these pages is included as "fair use", for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis only, and will be removed at the request of copyright owner(s). Report broken links, missing images and other errors to - overgrownpath at hotmail dot co dot uk

Comments

Pliable said…
Elsewhere Jessica Duchen says 'I can't decide whether I think it's A Good Thing because it gets music-making onto primetime TV for several weeks running...'

Jessica, did anyone ever tell you that public executions drew huge audiences during the French Revolution?

http://jessicamusic.blogspot.com/2007/11/wot-classical-music-on-primetime-tv.html
Jessica said…
Yes, they did, but I'm not sure that's entirely the point. After watching yesterday's episode I think this whole thing will prove just a drop in the ocean. Nobody will remember it this time next year. The most depressing thing about the programme is the way that the music itself is sidelined and chopped up. Evidently our friends at the Beeb don't think that viewers can cope with a whole movement of Mendelssohn.

Recent popular posts

Scott Ross and the paradox of genius

Classical music must woke up and smell the coffee

Why is the classical music industry anti-vax?

'I dig Strauss and Wagner – those cats are good'

Mikis Theodorakis' Songs of Freedom

Classical's elusive young audience wants chewy music

Watch this classical music movie or forever live in darkness

If this had been a Deutsche Grammophon session.....

Less Mahler is better Mahler

Great musicians deserve more than twenty-four hours of fame