Tuesday, May 06, 2008

Carter on Cage


'This reminded me that when Elliott Carter visited Keele University on October 17, 1977, he answered questions in front of an audience after a recital of his music. He was asked, "Mr. Carter, what do you think of John Cage?" and replied "I don't think of John Cage."'


This quote comes from editor Peter Dickinson's introduction to CageTalk (ISBN 158046 2375), a book which I strongly recommend. Dickinson's English roots and the fact that much of the material originates from BBC interviews gives this Cage anthology a refreshingly cosmopolitan feel. The interviewees include Merce Cunningham, Bonnie Bird, David Tudor, Virgil Thomson, Karlheinz Stockhausen, La Monte Young and Pauline Oliveros. I will be dipping into CageTalk again several more times, meanwhile Cage is happening here and Carter here.
Any copyrighted material on these pages is included as "fair use", for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis only, and will be removed at the request of copyright owner(s). Report broken links, missing images and errors to - overgrownpath at hotmail dot co dot uk

1 comment:

henryholland said...

He was asked, "Mr. Carter, what do you think of John Cage?" and replied "I don't think of John Cage."'

Hahaha, excellent.

Luigi Nono also didn't think highly of Cage's methods either: (from this article):

The collegiality of the Darmstadt School was short-lived, however. Nono could not tolerate Boulez and Stockhausen's sympathy for the work of John Cage, whose music was the most controversial feature of the 1958 Darmstadt summer school. The following year, Nono denounced Cage's uses of chance and indeterminacy in making compositional decisions as "spiritual suicide". Cage believed that every sound could become music; Nono took the Marxist view that it was the composer's responsibility to recognise that every sound was politically charged by its historical associations.

I'm certainly no fan of Cage's ideas or his music, but in this case, I'd say: Cage 1, Nono 0.